Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Invitees:

Wajahat Hussain (SEECS)?-, Saqib (GZHU)?; Johari (UNIMAS)?;  Adib (UUM)?; Fizi Jalil (MYREN);  Dr. Charnsak Srisawatsakul (Ubru), Les+, Bebo, Umar+

...

  1. insufficient understanding of the complexities in the cauality causality argumentation and related findings. 

    Adib responds: we have addressed IEEE access reviewers' comments carefully. complexities and even  validation can be further enhanced, but our data is a bit limited, we have only ten values  for each index. We have no data available for ALL indices in 2017 (the year this study was conducted), not even 2016. Values of all social economic indices re only available in 2015. I would suggest to consider this point in our next paper, where we can update our internet performance data to 2018, and hopefully other indices data are available as well.

  2. the relevant previous literature is not well addressed 

     Adib responds: Actually, we reduced LR session to minimize the paper size so it can meet the journal requirements. Adding more LR can be done, but then the size will be increased again. In fact, not many close and recent papers were published in this particular area. so it is not necessary to add more LR, especially we are not comparing our final model with them. 

  3. As a minor but still disturbing deficiency, references to the cited papers are incomplete. 
    Adib agrees and it is already amended

...

NUST: (Updated 5/3/2018))

No intern has joined Wajahat's Lab. So there is not much progress.

 They have shortlisted candidates for the task of managing the Pakistani MAs.The students will be given a stipend. As of 4/30/2018, they are still waiting for new students. The interns have not joined the lab yet. So the progress is a little slow.  Is there an update?

Wajahat proposes to get a list of the new Universities in Pakistan and contact them encouraging them to participate in PingER and set up MA. They have made a list of new university sites, communications networks, Labs in different regions of Pakistan (especially the remote regions) and will make contact.

 

  • The list of new universities is ready. Just need resource to engage them. 
  • Unsure how this is affected by lack of interns.

Wajahat is hoping to get few students to work on Master thesis related to pinger data. If possible kindly share ideas related to data analytics which he can share with students

  • Suggestions anyone?

 Wajahat also asked:

  •  “Has any work gone into to predicting the cause of failures(black out, flood, coup (turkey)) using pinger data?”
  • Les> there have been several case studies looking at the impacts of failures, however nothing on predicting failures. I am not sure how one might  use PinGER to predict the cause of a failure. For some cases (e.g. earthquakes, tsunamis, flood, coup), it is unclear to me how Network performance monitoring could add to other means of predicting the cause.
  • Wajahat's thinking is along the lines of "Regarding other sources, I was thinking, internet is the pulse of digital world. Other sources require additional setup that might not be a possibility in developing countries. Internet being a necessity and having other uses is still prevalent in these developing countries. Can it be used as a real time sensor."
  • Again I am  forwarding the question in case others in the team may have some suggestions?

There is an There is an upcoming grant call for projects between Pakistan and the US. Topics may be focused on cybersecurity, health, and education. It has not been announced yet. Wajahat will get the details and share them with the team as soon as they are available. It is interesting since getting a US partner appears to be a roadblock for many potential Pakistani responders. However, the topics may not be very related to PingER. NUST is looking at applying to set up a cyber lab. Getting the funding will be in competition with other Pakistani Universities. For cyber the main things we could think of from PingER were: quantifying what fraction of hosts block pings, punching holes in firewalls to allow pings, how to misuse ping (e.g. ping-of-death, or using anomalous ping packets to deduce the OS etc. flood pings for DOS), the host can respond to ping but applications do not work.  Fear of misuse of pings can result in the system administrator, network administrator or cybersecurity blocking pings. A possibility might be a study of what fraction of say working www/dns etc. apps (i.e. checking if a host responds to the relevant port) do not respond to pings.  This could be by application, by country or by region etc.  Also how to protect a remote pinger traceroute or server from being used in DOS attacks. As of 3/27/2018 there is no call so far. There was one last year, so Wajahat is expecting one. Emailed Wajahar 6/3/2018 asking for update. He responded "There is no call yet. There was one last year. May be change in the US-Pak policy. Just a guess."

 
We were SLAC was unable to gather data from:
  • 121.52.146.180 (kohat.edu.pk) down since Nov 22/2017. Wajahat recommends continuing at least until the new student is up to speed (3/8/2018). No data available 3/24/2018.
  • cae.seecs.edu.pk last time we were able to gather any data was February 27th.
  • pinger-ncp.ncp.edu.pk pings but can't gather data 8/11/2017 and 9/16/2017. Contacted. Pings but can't gather data 10/24/2017. They are in the process of restoring 1/17/2018. Still down February 28, 2018, await new student. (3/8/2018). No data 3/24/2018.
  • pinger.isra.edu.pk unable to gather data since 3/6/2018, also does not ping.
  • Wajahat says they will get these nodes up. These have been good nodes. They just need the weekly push. NUST will push them soon.

UNIMAS (No update 3/8/2018, 5/3/2018)

...