Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

By providing both VTrace (red) and Maxmind (blue)  routes, the results can be complementary in ascertaining the correct route. This is illustrated in the plots below from SLAC to a host in Braga Portugal (193.136.19.13). The left hand map shows how  VTrace accurately traces the route across the US, while Maxmind jumps from SLAC to the middle of the US, back to Berkeley and thence to Europe. This is shown in more detail in the W. Coast US map. Moving futherightfuther right, Vtrace shows the route through the Netherlands and the UK, while Maxmind  misses the Netherlands altogether. The Portugal detail indicates that Maxmind is more accurate in showing the final route to Braga. However, note that the Vtrace accuracy circles indicate the considerable uncertainty in the location of the last hop, hence improving ones one's confidence.  The traceroute figure which indicates that hops 12 and 13 are likely to be in the Netherlands and the UK given their naming conventions (note the top level domains .nl and .uk in the names). The TULIP plot shows how the  paucity of nearby landmarks (black market balloons) results in the poor geolocation of the Braga site.

...